ComfortandJoy

I worked with wood wicks from the Wooden Wick Co (now Makesy) for almost 4 years. I found them to be very inconsistent. I think it's the nature of the beast, so to speak. I switched to cotton wicks and never looked back. I use Premier and it has been a game changer. I used their regular and whisper wicks. From what I hear, the old wooden wicks worked much better but they apparently treated them with something that is considered toxic? Not sure, but that is what I heard.

I really like their FO's, but I don't see a Frasier Fir. All I know about is Frasier Fir and Citrus, which doesn't smell like the Frasier Fir from CS

I noticed changes when they started switching to their "Clean Scents". I used to get awesome throw from their Frasier Fir. Their new clean scent smells good OOB, but I get very little throw. So disappointed.

Currently, I'm really liking Aztec, Just Scent, Northwoods, Rustic Escentuals (WSP), and Flaming Candle. I'm using less Candle Science since they switched to their "Clean Scents". They are not burning consistently for me.

VERY informative! Thanks so much, @TallTayl 🙂 I thought Atkins & Pearce had csn replacement wicks, but I don't see them. Do you know of another source?

Hi Everyone! I have decided to begin my foray into the world of pillar candles using feather palm wax. Very sad that CS no longer carries the CSN wicks. I tried the Premier wicks I have on hand, and it seemed to do fairly well, but then the flame weakens. What other wicks should I try? Also, since I have learned that palm wax burns first down, then out, what should I be looking for in burn progression? For example, after two hours of burn, approximately what size should my melt pool be at that time? The candle in the pic was burned at two hour intervals for a total of 6 hours. How does that look? (I used a premier wick #777) And, finally, I poured the candle, then poked holes throughout the cooling process and did a final pour once the candle was completely cooled. The wax in that area was not feathered, but solid. Does anyone pour without poking holes? Thanks so much! 🙂

Oh, wow! I didn't know WSP bought Just Scent too. I use a few of their FO's and really like them. Hopefully, things won't change.

I've always used the Beach from WSP. I like it better than the one from NG. It was a great seller for me.

Candle Science discontinued Cargill waxes because of this. And yet, CS continues to use vessels imported from China, one of the worst human rights violators in the world.

Sure! I am happy to help in any way I can. @jpmakescandles As others have shared, be prepared for inconsistencies. I, too had great burning wood wick candles. But, I had many more that burned poorly/inconsistently enough to cause me to shy away from selling them. I used wooden wicks for 3 years, and finally had to acknowledge that it was the wicks that were causing the problem. I used mostly soy (and different ones, including Freedom Wax) I also tried several coconut waxes, including different vessels. I really, really tried. Aside from major inconsistencies, there was the problem with the wicks sputtering black soot/specs into the wax toward the end of the burn. It happened more often than not. As @TallTayl said, wood by nature is inconsistent. There was a time that wood wicks did burn well and consistently, but it was more of a composite material that compensated for the inconsistency. Sadly, they are no longer available. I am now using cotton wicks and I am amazed at the difference. I FINALLY have candles burning well, and WAY more consistently. I almost can't believe it, after all I went through with wood wicks. All that being said, the greatest freedom you have is finding out for yourself. So, go ahead and make your own discoveries. It will always be the best way to learn. I have a ton of wooden wicks I'd like to pass along, so if you're interested, let me know! I have a few sample packs as well.

What @ErronB said

Wax, wick, wood - definitely not a good combination. I am not in any way convinced that "treating" the wood is a failsafe.

haha! Oh my goodness! Best mushroom ever! 😂

I can't believe I held on for so long. 😑

Yep! This happened to me on more than one occasion.

Concurring with what @ErronB said. I tried getting wood wicks to work in my candles for more than 3 years. I used all kinds of wax blends, but no matter what I tried, they never performed consistently enough to make me confident enough to sell. I tried all of the wick varieties by Wooden Wick Co. I have come to the conclusion that wood wicks are inherently inconsistent by nature. There were other wood wicks from years ago that were formed with a homogenized mixture of wood and binding material. I hear they worked well. Sad they are no longer available. I've switched to regular cotton type wicks and I'm finally achieving much more consistent results.

haha! You're a genius!

I'm sad to say, nowhere at this point. It took me 3 years (I don't give up that easily) to finally realize this type of wood wick manufacture is inherently inconsistent.

I agree! I don't see them coming out with a consistent wood wick anytime soon. Think, never!

I completely concur with @Busy Bee on wooden wicks. Fun for personal use, but I cannot recommend them for production level commercial orders. I have finally thrown in the towel after 3.5 years of trying. (And, boy, did I try!) Wood, by nature, is inconsistent, and not something you want if you ever want to have a consistent line of candles. I never used them, but the older wood wicks were made up of a composite wood material, compensating for the lack of consistency. Too bad they are no longer around. I get really angry thinking that one company holds the patent on wood wicks. They make a crappy product.

I tested it a while back. Definitely a hard wax, so you'll have to wick accordingly. Throws well!

Hi Karen! I was testing with those jars about a year ago. I had good success with them, so I checked with C&S to see if they had a steady supply. They told me that once they run out, they will no longer carry them.

What size/type wood wick are you using? Soy wax usually needs the booster wood wicks. I would try to use just the wax without mica until you get better acquainted with wood wicks.

I love Spiced Chestnut from FC!

Thank you so much! I just purchase Pumpkin Cookie Crunch from Just Scent, and it smells almost exactly like RE's Pumpkin Creme Brulee! Hopefully, it will throw well!