The green irish tweed and irish spring from FBD are two totally different smelling fo's... in my soap recipe anyways. Scented the only other Irish Spring that I've tried is from Village Craft here in Canada. It's not bad, but it's definately not Fragrance by Design.... smells nothing like it. and of course it is one of my best sellers darn!!! I've got about 3 ounces left, so I can make one smaller batch, then after I'll be stuck!!