Honestly, I don't think either of them have a very good scent throw. I made a smelly jelly for my bathroom, but used 1oz of FO. I have it sitting on the back of the toilet, and can only smell it when I'm right there at the toilet. Can't smell it in much of the bathroom (I have a LONG narrow bathroom though). The beads do ok in my car. I wouldn't count on either of these if you were wanting to scent a large room or anything.